Low Appraisal in San Francisco? A Seller’s Guide to Appealing and Winning
How to Successfully Appeal a Low Appraisal on Your San Francisco Home
You’ve accepted an offer on your San Francisco property. Everything seems to be moving forward. Then, suddenly, the appraisal report comes in low. This is a major setback. In fact, it can cost you thousands of dollars and could even jeopardize the entire deal.
The good news, however, is that you have options. Low appraisals happen in San Francisco’s complex market. Still, you can fight back. With the right strategy and strong evidence, you can successfully challenge the valuation.
Therefore, this guide will walk you through the essential steps. Learn how to appeal a low appraisal and, ultimately, protect your home’s value.
Why a Low Appraisal Is a Problem
An appraisal below the purchase price creates a “valuation gap.” Consequently, this becomes a problem because lenders only finance a mortgage based on the appraised value, not the higher sale price. This gap causes several issues:
- First, financing can fail. The buyer may not get the full loan they need.
- Additionally, the buyer would have to pay the difference in cash, which many cannot afford.
- As a result, you may feel pressure to lower your price to match the appraisal.
- Finally, if you can’t find a solution, the sale could be cancelled.
Before you can fight back, you need to understand why it happened. For instance, common reasons include appraisers using outdated comps or not understanding your specific micro-neighborhood. They may have also overlooked your recent home renovations.
Your 7-Step Action Plan to Challenge a Low Appraisal
Follow these steps methodically to build the strongest possible case.
Step 1: Review the Appraisal Report for Errors
To begin, get a copy of the appraisal report. Review it carefully for any mistakes. Specifically, look for factual inaccuracies, as these are often the easiest errors to correct.
- Incorrect Property Details: For example, check the square footage, bedroom/bathroom counts, and lot size.
- Missing Upgrades: Did the appraiser miss your new kitchen, bathroom, or home office?
- Inaccurate Market Data: Similarly, does the report use wrong information about the local market?
Be sure to document every error you find. This information will be the foundation of your appeal.
Step 2: Find Better Comparable Sales (Comps)
Next, find better comps. This is where local market knowledge is critical. An appraiser might not know your specific block. As a result, they may use comps that are too far away. Your agent should help you find comps that are:
- Hyper-Local: Located within a half-mile.
- Recent: Sold in the last 90 days.
- Truly Similar: Matching your home in size, age, and condition.
- In the Same School District: This is a key value driver in SF.
Step 3: Highlight Your Property’s Unique Features
In addition, you should highlight your property’s unique features. Standard appraisal forms often miss what makes an SF home special. Therefore, create a list of everything that adds value, such as:
- Premium Views: Like views of the Golden Gate Bridge, the Bay, or the city.
- High-End Upgrades: Such as solar panels, a chef’s kitchen, or smart home systems.
- Location Perks: Proximity to MUNI/BART, parks, or top-rated schools.
- Structural Advantages: Likewise, mention a large yard, a legal in-law unit, or seismic retrofitting.
Step 4: Compile Your Supporting Documentation
Furthermore, facts and figures are your best friends in an appeal. To that end, gather all the paperwork you can to support your claims. This includes:
- Receipts and permits for all recent improvements.
- Official floor plans showing the correct square footage.
- Details on the better comparable sales you found.
- HOA documents that list community amenities.
Step 5: Formally Request a Reconsideration of Value (ROV)
Once your case is built, it’s time for a formal appeal. This is called a Reconsideration of Value (ROV). The buyer’s lender must submit it. You cannot submit it directly. However, you and your agent are still responsible for providing all the necessary information.
Step 6: Be Prepared with a Backup Plan
An appeal is not always successful. For this reason, it’s wise to have a backup plan. Discuss these options with your agent while you wait:
- First, you could renegotiate the price with the buyer.
- Alternatively, ask the buyer to pay the difference in cash.
- Also, consider paying for a second, independent appraisal.
- If all else fails, put the home back on the market.
Step 7: Partner with an Experienced San Francisco Agent
Finally, partner with an experienced SF agent. Indeed, this may be your most important step. Appealing an appraisal requires deep local knowledge. An experienced agent understands the city’s market. They also know how to build a strong case for an ROV. They are your most valuable advocate in this process.
Conclusion: Take Control of the Situation
In short, a low appraisal is a hurdle, not a dead end. Mistakes in valuation can happen in San Francisco’s market. Ultimately, the key is to respond quickly. Then, build a case with strong evidence and work with a real estate professional who knows the system. By being proactive, you can protect your investment and keep your home sale on track.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: Can a seller directly appeal a low appraisal?
No. The formal appeal (ROV) must be started by the buyer through their lender. This is because the lender is the appraiser’s client. However, you and your agent are responsible for gathering the evidence for the appeal.
Q2: How often are appraisal appeals successful in San Francisco?
Success rates vary. But they are highest when your appeal uses clear, objective evidence. Specifically, this includes factual errors in the report or better comparable sales that the appraiser missed.
Q3: What happens if the appraisal value doesn’t change after the appeal?
If the appeal is denied, then you must move to your backup plan. This could mean renegotiating the price. The buyer might also agree to pay the difference in cash. Otherwise, you may need to cancel the contract and put your home back on the market.
Comments
Post a Comment